Published December 27, 2023
Fulfillment by Amazon vs Wayfair CastleGate: A Supplier's Perspective
inpractise.com/articles/fulfillment-by-amazon-vs-wayfair-castlegate-a-suppliers-perspective
Executive Bio
Furniture Retailer (Amazon & Wayfair)
Interview Transcript
Disclaimer: This interview is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a basis for investment decisions. In Practise is an independent publisher and all opinions expressed by guests are solely their own opinions and do not reflect the opinion of In Practise.
This is a snippet of the transcript.to get full access.
Compared to Wayfair's Asia consolidation service, where you contract a manufacturer in Asia, get the goods out, consolidate them in a warehouse before sending them through ocean freight, does Amazon offer this service?
Yes, both Wayfair and Amazon offer the consolidation process directly from import or they also handle the domestic pickup. They both function similarly. However, my experience with Wayfair's Asia consolidation has been more in-depth and streamlined. This is because with Wayfair, you have a more relationship-based experience with the account manager, supply chain personnel, and traffic. So, it's easier to get things done even if they're not necessarily outlined in a mechanical way in their portal. You can talk to someone and get it done. On the other hand, with Amazon, you're at the mercy of their system and Seller Central to figure out all the steps and ensure you're not going to incur some overage charge or you're not setting it up the right way. For instance, with our last shipment, we had to cancel it two or three times because we kept catching mistakes, like forgetting to add something, or the dimensions not being quite right, or needing to push the pickup day out. It's much more complex under the Amazon lens.
This is a snippet of the transcript.to get full access.
How much would it cost you to transport the same container from LA to your own warehouse in Massachusetts?
I don't have the exact figure, but I know it would be less than what you'd pay for the white glove service provided by CastleGate or Amazon. The cost would be lower given your established relationship and freight rates with the carrier.
This is a snippet of the transcript.to get full access.
At what point would you enter the inventory on Seller Central?
From Amazon's perspective, we don't want to ship using the fulfillment by merchant method because it doesn't provide the speed badging. Customers come to Amazon for a fast shopping experience. They expect goods within 24 to 48 hours. This can only be achieved by shipping through FBA. We would never ship fulfillment by merchant because it doesn't serve the end user well.
Free Sample of 50+ Interviews
Sign up to test our content quality with a free sample of 50+ interviews.
Or contact sales for full access
Related Content

Wayfair: Multichannel Monetization & Competitive Positioning
Former Senior Operations Executive at Wayfair

The Trade Desk: Strategic Value of Ventura OS
Former Product Lead, Ventura CTV OS at The Trade Desk

InPost: Yodel’s Acquisition and the UK Out-of-Home Market
Former Director at Yodel

Allegro: Smart Unit Economics & Inpost Relationship
Former Director at Allegro
© 2024 In Practise. All rights reserved. This material is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice.